Which photo of Bailey?
 

I will be doing a monochromatic painting of Bailey using one of these photos. Her mother likes the 3/4 view because she prefers that softer more angelic smile. I like the smile too, however I feel I'd be more successful at getting a likeness with the strait-on view with it's more straightforward lighting and clarity. I've had trouble with that 3/4 view before, but this shot sure is cute. The mother is ok with either shot.

Wow. What great pictures!

I'd have to do two portraits. But if I was forced to choose, I'd go for the frontal view. It's hard to explain, but it has a quality that seems honest and has more depth.

I love them both. You're sure to do great things with this little model. There's a very modern feel to her, with the haircut and the blouse. I have grown tired of the nostalgic costumed portraits. Nothing is more interesting than today's people, caught up in today. Does any of this make sense? Be sure to post your finished work.

I can't take credit for the photography. These were taken by a professional as Bailey was getting ready to be in a wedding--before all the flower girl headgear.

Even though it is slightly out of focus, I vote for the 3/4 view. It shows more personality. One can see a bit of the mischievous imp emerging.

Hi April,

I suppose you cannot take your own photos, so I prefer the 1st one.

Hi April,

Personally I would go with #2 for a few reasons: it's more in focus (I don't feel #1 has enough light/dark information or detail to work with), # 2 has a more atypical and striking look as a composition, and I like the expression in #2 more, also. Just my 2 cents.

Paint them both, then look at your results. If they are not up to par, either re-shoot or decline the job.

Very good advice!