Hi Mike,
I think both could make valid paintings - the first in more subdued colors in a classical style, the second seems to me a good candidate for colorful pastels or a loose high chroma oil, especially if you're intrigued by the blue exterior light.
May I suggest:
- should you choose the first one, consider cropping it differently. I think there is a great risk that, if not done right, the painting could end up being a portrait of a lamp.
- should you paint the second one, that you "reconcile" the juxtaposition of the casual outfit vs. the formal interior. Additionally, I would NOT have the left arm just sharply ending like that, with the left hand in the lap (which is very unladylike, and insulting to the subject in a way, especially when she's doing something as gentle and dignified as reading).
- hope that doesn't sound too odd of an interpretation.
Good luck with either.
Linda
|